The Secret Behind Elite Traders in the Financial Markets: Insights from the Psychology of Trading

By Geva Gazit – Active trader since 2005 in capital markets and futures trading

Introduction

In the world of financial markets—and especially in the futures market—there are select individuals who manage to generate consistent, powerful, and profitable results over time. These are the elite traders. They are not born this way, but are built gradually through a set of mental tools, psychological insights, and exceptional self-management skills.

What truly transforms an average trader into an elite one? Is it exceptional intelligence, fast calculation abilities, or perhaps a breakthrough strategic approach? The answer often lies in a less comfortable place—within the trader’s own mindset.

In this article, we will dive into five critical elements of professional trading success, as identified in psychological studies of the financial markets, especially futures trading. We will highlight the major challenges traders face and present the solutions that mark the difference between an amateur and a professional.

1. Emotional Control – The Critical Component for Trading Success

Emotional control is the key factor for success in trading—it’s what separates impulsive reactions from strategic action. Successful traders do not act out of fear, frustration, or greed, but rather from calmness and clarity. They don’t let a temporary loss break their trading concept, nor do they allow a single win to distort their strategic outlook.

The real test of emotional control arises during challenging trades—the moment the chart moves against you, and the temptation to “just close it” for relief appears. This is precisely the moment when elite traders pause, breathe, and make a decision based on a pre-defined plan, not gut feeling.

A trader who fails to develop emotional control will continue to fail, because in the capital markets—like any competitive arena—emotional control is the true key to managing a stable and profitable trading process.

Problem:
Traders struggle with fear, greed, and frustration. These emotions override strategic responses and dominate decisions instead of the plan.

Practical Solutions:

1. Meditation and Mindfulness – Daily practice of 10–20 minutes improves emotional control. A study from Investopedia showed increased self-awareness and reduced impulsive responses.
2. Automatic Stop-Loss – Setting a loss threshold helps avoid panic and turns intuitive decisions into structured actions.
3. Emotional Journal – Tracking moods before/during/after trades allows recognition of recurring emotional patterns.

Supporting Research:

• Norman Welz – 95% of our actions are subconscious. Winning traders adopt mental training and even hypnosis to improve discipline.
• Loss Aversion Phenomenon – Analyzed over 28 million trades and found that traders avoid short-term losses, leading to larger long-term losses.

2. Self-Discipline – The Foundation of Elite Traders

Self-discipline is the foundation on which elite traders are built. Without strict adherence to rules, strategies, and a daily routine—there is no trading, only gambling. Professional trading is more akin to brain surgery than poker.

Once trading becomes a daily reflex, not an emotional whim, self-discipline transforms from a burden into a habit. And it is precisely during difficult trading days, when the market is volatile and unpredictable, that the true value of discipline shines—elite traders maintain the same consistency, the same stops, and the same analysis—no matter what.

Even after years in the market, traders fail when they neglect basic rules. That’s why self-discipline remains the critical foundation for success—even for seasoned traders.

Problem:
Inconsistency in daily actions leads to impulsive decisions and reliance on intuition alone.

Practical Solutions:

1. Fixed Daily Trading Plan – Including clear entry and exit criteria and predefined trading hours.
2. Defined Standards – Rules like “No more than 3 trades per day” and a firm commitment to follow them.
3. Time Management Apps – Tools such as Pomodoro or Forest improve focus and concentration.

Supporting Research:

• Gary Stone emphasizes the importance of maintaining strict personal discipline and minimizing real-time errors.
• A review from Quantified Strategies outlines rigorous planning and analysis methods that lead to consistent results.

3. Probabilistic Thinking – The Secret to Long-Term Success

Probabilistic thinking is the key to long-term success because it shifts the trader’s focus from a single outcome to the overall process. Trading is not a game of fairness—it’s a game of statistical advantage.

Traders who do not adopt probabilistic thinking are doomed to an emotional roller coaster—every loss feels like a personal failure, and every win like divine justice. However, in the midst of any trade sequence—positive or negative—probabilistic thinking helps the trader stay calm, understand the data, and perform at their best.

A professional trader understands that in the end, probabilistic thinking provides the inner confidence and stability to keep trading—even in the face of temporary losses.

Problem:
Traders are influenced by specific profits or losses and fail to understand the importance of working with long-term statistical edge.

Practical Solutions:

1. Edge Analysis – Evaluating if a trade is supported by statistics, not emotion. Even a loss is acceptable if it aligns with a profitable model.
2. Acceptance of Losing Streaks – Understanding that loss clusters are part of the statistical model prevents irrational quitting.
3. Statistical Trade Journal – Tracking risk/reward ratios, win/loss percentages—reinforces probabilistic thinking.

Supporting Research:

• Archival research on Prospect Theory proves the widespread impact of loss aversion among traders.
• Models by Lim & Gorse in high-frequency trading point to probabilistic thinking as a major tool for handling uncertainty.

4. Continuous Self-Analysis – The Most Painful, Yet Most Effective Mirror

Continuous self-analysis is the trader’s most painful yet most effective mirror. Without it, the trader is doomed to repeat the same mistakes over and over again. Progress in trading is not linear — it requires honest and accurate self-reflection.

In the daily grind, it’s easy to ignore bad decisions — to blame the market, the news, or the broker. But Continuous self-analysis — examining trades, emotions, and decision-making — is something only elite traders truly practice.

Anyone who wants to survive and succeed long-term must accept that continuous self-analysis is the core tool for consistent improvement, systematic correction, and genuine professional growth.

Problem:
Lack of self-monitoring leads to repeated mistakes and stagnation in development.

Practical Solutions:

1. Video/Audio Journaling – Verbally document the trade’s rationale and emotional states in real time for future review.
2. Structured Weekly Reviews – Set aside time each week to systematically evaluate your decisions, trades, and emotional responses.
3. Psychological Coaching – Ongoing support from a trading coach or performance psychologist improves self-awareness and decision-making clarity.

Research Highlights:

• Dr. Brett Steenbarger emphasizes that elite traders document and analyze their mental and emotional performance just like athletes.
• Studies from the Journal of Behavioral Finance show that structured self-reflection improves long-term profitability by up to 20%.

5. Identity Shift – From Trader to Professional

The final element that separates great traders from amateurs is a shift in identity. It’s not just about what you do — it’s about who you become. Professional traders don’t define themselves by wins or losses, but by consistency, process, and internal standards.

Once trading becomes part of your identity, not just an activity, everything changes. You wake up with purpose. You treat your preparation like a surgeon treats a procedure. You stop seeking excitement and start seeking efficiency.

Without this identity shift, every market move is personal. Every loss is a blow to self-worth. But when you operate from the identity of a professional, you build resilience, humility, and longevity.

Problem:
Traders link their self-worth to results and struggle to maintain consistency when things go wrong.

Practical Solutions:

1. Morning Routine & Visualization – Start each day like an athlete: visualize discipline, execution, and calmness.
2. Professional Environment – Treat your trading station like a workplace, not a game — clean desk, clear schedule, and planned breaks.
3. Mentorship & Community – Surround yourself with like-minded professionals who reinforce a culture of discipline and performance.

Research Highlights:

• Studies on “Identity-Based Habits” by James Clear show that long-term change stems from shifting identity, not just setting goals.
• Mark Douglas, author of Trading in the Zone, highlighted that elite traders act from a stable inner identity, not external outcomes.

Conclusion: The Mental Edge That Creates Super-Traders

Becoming an elite trader is not about secret indicators or ultra-fast calculations. It’s about cultivating a deep internal structure — one built on emotional control, discipline, probabilistic thinking, continuous self-assessment, and a professional identity.

These are not talents. They are skills. And like any skill, they can be learned, practiced, and strengthened — if you’re willing to do the work.

True success in the financial markets is not reserved for the gifted. It’s reserved for those who are mentally prepared.

Student Reviews of Geva Gazit’s Gold Course

1. Michael Rosenberg – New York, USA:

“I studied trading in other places, but only in Geva’s Gold Course did I truly understand what it means to manage a deal. The daily support, and the meticulousness of personal analysis of each deal – that’s what changed everything for me. Geva is not just a teacher – he is a true mentor.”

2. Lucía Fernandez – Madrid, Spain:

“I come from a background in psychology, and that’s exactly why I saw how precisely the Gold Course is structured. Geva manages to combine professional content with emotional depth, and gave me tools to deal with fears and doubts. Today I trade ES and NQ and feel in control.”

3. Yossi Ben-Haim – Haifa, Israel:

“I thought I knew the market, until I joined Geva’s course. I received a framework, order, support – and most importantly, a deep understanding of what makes deals succeed or fail. This is not just another course – it is a life-changing process.”

________________________________________

“Alternative Trader” – A Must-Read Book

The book “Alternative Trader” is much more than a trading guide – it is a psychological and strategic journey deep into the world of trading. It presents a refreshing and practical approach, written from field experience rather than theory. Anyone who wants to understand the real secrets behind super traders – will find insights, tools and real examples here.

About the Author: Geva Gazit

Geva Gazit is a veteran futures trader, mentor, and creator of the 3D Trading Method, specializing in correlation-based and spread trading. Since 2005, he has trained hundreds of traders using advanced techniques in trading psychology, risk management, and strategic execution.

Learn more at gevatrade.com.